'Where's the body?' family's lawsuit asks Avondale cemetery - NOLA.com
Mar 11, 2019The family of Shelton Guthrie Sr. says Restlawn Cemetery failed to bury him on property he purchased in 1973, according to a lawsuit filed in 24th Judicial District Court.(NOLA.com The Times-Picayune)The family of a West Bank man who died in January is suing Restlawn Park Cemetery because it can't specify where it buried him. Relatives allege the Avondale cemetery was negligent when it decided to lay Sheldon Guthrie Sr. to rest outside their presence and in a plot other than the one he bought. Guthrie and his wife, Vivian Boudreaux Guthrie, bought two adjacent "lawn lots'' in 1973 in the cemetery's Garden of Honor off U.S. 90. The next year, they received a deed for the land, the lawsuit said.On Jan. 26, Guthrie died. After a Jan. 31 funeral at Mothe Funeral Home, according to the suit, a burial service took place at Restlawn -- but not at the grave site that the couple bought.When Guthrie's daughter, Sylvia Pearson Chagnard, returned to the cemetery Feb. 9 to buy a headstone, she learned her father had been buried elsewhere. The suit says cemetery staff told her that a tree prevented workers from digging at the assigned spot. The place where Guthrie was buried lacked an adjoining empty plot for his wife and appeared to be another man's gravesite as indicated by the headstone, according to the suit.The family thinks Guthrie's remains have been exhumed, moved and reburied "one or more times'' without their consent. Sheldon Guthrie Sr. "To this day, they have been unable to confirm for themselves the whereabouts of their father's remains, instead having to rely upon representations made by Restlawn representatives who have been less than forthcoming and non-communicative with plaintiffs,'' the suit said. "There is a distinct possibility that the remains of Mr. Guthrie have been lost." The suit was filed in March in 24th Judicial District Court in Gretna. The case is assigned to Judge Danyelle Taylor.In addition to Guthrie's widow and daughter, other plaintiffs include sons S...